Review of “The White People” (1904)
Arthur Machen (writer).
Read in 2026.
By way of explaining an unusual theory of ethics, an eccentric on the outskirts of London lets a visitor read the diary of a young witch.
Mikhail Bakhtin was barely born when Machen wrote this story. It is my understanding that what Machen aims for, in both levels of “The White People”, is strongly linked to the Carnivalesque features that Bakhtin would later identify in Rabelais and other authors, whom both men loved. In this story and elsewhere, Machen outlines his competing theory of “ecstasy”, clearly stumbling trying to link it to ethics through Gilles de Rais of all people. Bakhtin struck closer to the truth. Even so, I appreciate the framing device of this short story more than the hypodiegesis, which is the diary itself. That seems to be a minority opinion.
There is absolutely a charm in Machen inventing Aklo, but in the hypodiegesis, it looks to me like Machen is trying to make a superstitious folktale seem scary mainly by omitting facts and spinning some surreal imagery into the taboos. H. P. Lovecraft, who admired Machen, would do far better a couple of decades later by leaving the folklore of human-centric witchcraft behind.
References to this work: “The Dreams in the Witch House” (1933), Evangelion: 3.0+1.01 Thrice Upon a Time (2021).